Ice Cream Cakes

At all of our Madison-area ice cream shoppes (except for our Atwood walk up window) you can purchase a variety of pre-made and custom-made ice cream cakes.Check out more details such as flavors, pricing and a guide to ordering below, or call our cake specialist, Diane, at 608-441-5248 for more details.

Jump to:

Ordering Guide

A selection of premade cakes will always be available for last minute purchasing at each of our ice cream shoppes. To order a custom cake, please note the following timelines.

  • If you're picking up from our Sequoya ice cream shoppe:
    • Orders for Tuesday-Friday require a minimum of 24 hours notice.
    • Orders for Saturday-Monday should be arranged by the previous Friday at Noon.
  • If you're picking up from our State Street or Camelot ice cream shoppes:
    • Orders for Tuesday-Friday require a minimum of 48-72 hours notice.
    • Orders for Saturday-Monday should be arranged by the previous Friday at Noon.

Custom Cake Choices

  • Cake size
  • Ice cream flavor
    • Not all ice creams are carried on site, so longer order times will help guarantee availability of choices.
  • 1/2 cake and 1/2 ice cream or all ice cream
  • Chocolate, yellow or marble cake
  • Chocolate or vanilla frosting base
  • Custom decoration ideas (colors, messages, etc.)
    • Character cake kits and edible pictures are available for an extra $8. Extra lead time is needed for edible pictures.
  • Gluten-free options are available.
    • *The ice cream is made in a facility that uses, soy, nut, gluten and dairy products.

Pre-made Cake Choices

We commonly have the following pre-made cakes in stock at our three ice cream shoppes:

  • 8" round ice cream cakes
    • Turtle
    • Ultimate Oreo
    • Peanut Butter Cup
    • Cookie Dough
    • Zanzibar Chocolate
    • Old Fashioned Vanilla
    • Mint Chip ice cream
    • Caramel Chaos ice cream
  • 8" ice cream torte cakes
    • Ultimate Oreo Dirt Torte
    • French Silk Dream Torte
    • Grasshopper Torte
  • 1/4 sheet ice cream cakes
    • Turtle ice cream with x cake
    • Ultimate Oreo ice cream with x cake
    • Peanut Butter Cup with x cake
    • Old Fashioned Vanilla with x cake
  • Pies of assorted flavors

To check on the current availability of the above flavors and of the assorted ice cream pies or to reserve a pre-made cake, call the shoppe you wish to pick up from.

Cake Sizes, Servings and Pricing

  • 4" babycake 2-3 servings $8.95
    8" round cake 15-20 servings $29.95
    1/4 sheet (rectangular) 25-30 servings $45.99
    1/2 sheet (rectangular)
    45-55 servings $68.99, $30 deposit required
    8" pie 10-15 servings

For payments, we accept Visa, Mastercard, Discover or cash.

Cake Handling Instructions

  • Let the cake sit at room temperature for 10-15 minutes before serving.
  • Use a knife dipped in cold water for clean edges when cutting.
  • Best if used within 1-2 weeks of when the cake is initially cut into.
  • Don't allow the cake to sit in your home freezer too long or it will absorb the scents from within your freezer.